NPR’s Ailsa Chang talks with filmmaker Vinay Shukla and journalist Ravish Kumar in regards to the new documentary Whereas We Watched.
AILSA CHANG, HOST:
Right here within the U.S., Individuals who watch Fox Information seemingly do not watch CNN, and that goes each methods. In India, the media panorama has turn into an much more deeply divided echo chamber. And lately, with the rise of Hindu nationalism, some Indian information anchors have overtly sided with Prime Minister Narendra Modi throughout broadcasts, labeling critics of the Modi authorities anti-nationalists.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED JOURNALIST #1: For each Indian soldier killed, 100 Pakistani troopers killed. There’s a very sturdy sentiment now. And the…
UNIDENTIFIED JOURNALIST #2: Anti-nationals in India – they should be made to pay, too.
CHANG: One journalist who discovered himself focused by these remarks, accused of being an anti-nationalist, is Ravish Kumar.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
RAVISH KUMAR: Indian media is in a state of disaster, and this disaster shouldn’t be unintended or random however systemic and structural.
CHANG: Kumar was a information anchor and senior government editor for the information community NDTV in New Delhi for a few years. The documentary “Whereas We Watched” tracks his life as a journalist on the heart of these political fights at a time when his personal newsroom was crumbling round him. Vinay Shukla directed the movie, which has now received a Peabody Award.
VINAY SHUKLA: After I got here throughout Ravish, I used to be very stunned. You’ll fairly often hear information anchors saying issues like, we’re right here to serve the viewers, and regardless of the viewers needs, we’ll ship. After I got here throughout Ravish’s broadcast, with him, I discovered a information anchor who was not solely questioning the federal government but in addition questioning the audiences.
CHANG: After I spoke with Shukla final 12 months alongside along with his documentary topic, Ravish Kumar, I requested Kumar why he felt the necessity to start talking out to his viewers, to the remainder of the world in regards to the state of Indian media.
KUMAR: These media are usually not working for dissemination of data. They’re working exhausting to cease info reaching to the viewers and to the voters. This example could be very severe. This isn’t a routine story of media decline, I believe.
CHANG: There are a number of moments on this movie the place you get dying threats. Like, at one level, whilst you’re fielding menacing telephone calls, you begin singing a patriotic Indian tune to somebody who’s attacking you on the telephone.
(SOUNDBITE OF DOCUMENTARY, “WHILE WE WATCHED”)
KUMAR: (Singing in non-English language).
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: (Non-English language spoken).
KUMAR: (Singing in non-English language).
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: (Non-English language spoken).
KUMAR: (Singing in non-English language).
CHANG: I used to be so struck by that second as a result of I do not understand how I’d really feel if I had been listening to somebody yell at me like that. What possessed you to interrupt into tune like that proper on the telephone?
KUMAR: To only – to make him settle down. I requested him, are you able to sing a tune with me? We each love nation, so let’s sing. And all of the sudden he fell into my entice and began singing. And also you heard that…
CHANG: It was like a lullaby is what you are saying.
KUMAR: Yeah. Yeah. But it surely’s not good to listen to when somebody is threatening you, your daughters, your spouse, your life. It hurts you.
CHANG: Properly, some outstanding issues occurred at NDTV, Vinay, as you had been filming this documentary. For instance, a lot of Ravish’s colleagues started abandoning the community because the newsroom begins to crumble. There’s this different scene within the movie the place the community’s broadcast seems to only actually freeze on TVs throughout India. Are you able to discuss what occurred in that second when the published froze?
SHUKLA: I imply, the published would freeze sporadically and in numerous areas, not essentially all throughout India. However these are – you realize, it is troublesome to seek out out why that form of stuff was taking place. But it surely was a quite common incidence with Ravish’s present.
CHANG: Did you suppose the federal government was taking part in a direct function in that?
SHUKLA: I can not say with absolute certainty that the federal government was doing it with out the proof to again it up, proper? That is the place you require a really sturdy journalism kicking in and investigating why that is taking place. Sadly, investigative journalism in India proper now has taken a success.
CHANG: Proper.
SHUKLA: So these are the challenges. We’re left with numerous questions. It is unlucky.
CHANG: However I’m curious. What was the story that you simply got down to inform, Vinay, firstly of this venture? And the way a lot did that change by the point you had been ending the movie? Did you see an evolution in your individual storytelling, in your targets?
SHUKLA: After I began filming this venture, I keep in mind considering that Ravish – he has been doing this for practically 25 years after I approached him. And I assumed it will likely be some huge, swanky workplace whereby, you realize, he’ll have a big crew of people who find themselves working with him as a result of, you realize, I – my solely reference for the way it could possibly be was, like, movies. I had seen these huge form of newsroom thrillers…
CHANG: Proper.
SHUKLA: …During which a few individuals, you realize, stand across the desk and say, we’re doing this story and that. You already know, that is how we’re going to change every part. I acquired to NDTV, and I noticed him and his colleagues function in – with essentially the most minimal groups. Like, Ravish’s crew, at any level, was lower than 5 individuals. And, you realize, the primary day I used to be there on the shoot, I keep in mind seeing a cake being lower.
CHANG: As a result of anyone was leaving the workplace.
SHUKLA: And anyone was leaving the workplace. And it was a really, very truthfully tragic second whenever you see anyone who’s dedicated, you realize, practically three a long time, twenty years of their life to a career, and at some point they’re requested to go away not due to their very own flaws however due to the place the career is now at. So at that time, I spotted that this movie is just like the “Titanic,” however it’s not about Jack and Rose. It is in regards to the individuals who determined to remain again on the Titanic and exit taking part in their violins…
CHANG: Wow.
SHUKLA: …Concerning the people who find themselves nonetheless attempting to do their job and scuffling with it.
CHANG: Ravish, by the top of this movie, you had been nonetheless at NDTV. However, in fact, that modified final 12 months, when a billionaire who’s aligned with Prime Minister Modi – his title is Gautam Adani – he took over the community. And that is whenever you lastly resigned. Now you host a present on YouTube. Are you able to discuss in regards to the determination to go away NDTV?
KUMAR: My conscience advised me that I shouldn’t be working with him. After former proprietor of NDTV Radhika Roy and Prannoy Roy – as soon as they depart NDTV, NDTV means to me nothing. It would turn into a sort of propaganda machine or another information channels.
CHANG: What does it really feel wish to be preventing in your survival on YouTube? As somebody who’s been in mainstream broadcast media for many years, what’s that wish to be on a platform like YouTube now?
SHUKLA: I get pleasure from my work. I have no idea what’s the lifetime of my YouTube channel. So it’s within the palms of YouTube, some unknown supervisor, some unknown authority. However until now, I am very grateful to the YouTube that has been capable of assist my household, to assist my life…
CHANG: And to provide you a voice.
SHUKLA: …And to provide you a voice, which – no Indian information channels and newspapers have mustered braveness to provide me a single columnist’s house to put in writing right here no matter you need to write. However the one means is to maintain working. And that is the hope. Many days I get 1 million views in a single hour. Many days I get 2 million views in two hours. So that is the sort of expertise I’m having with the YouTube viewers. They’re the hope, really.
CHANG: That was longtime Indian journalist Ravish Kumar and Vinay Shukla, who directed the documentary “Whereas We Watched.” The movie simply received a Peabody Award this month.
Copyright © 2024 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content will not be in its last type and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability might range. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.
