Keir Starmer’s Labour social gathering has gained the UK normal election in a landslide. Its big majority ought to, in idea, give Starmer the clout to see via most of his political agenda. However in actuality, the victory celebrations may show short-lived, given the scale of the challenges in entrance of him.
When Tony Blair got here to energy in 1997, he inherited a robust financial system and a tide of booming nationwide optimism. Starmer, against this, inherits an financial system within the doldrums and a mandate seemingly extra motivated by a want to take away the Conservatives than by enthusiasm for Labour’s manifesto.
Need extra politics protection from tutorial consultants? Each week, we carry you knowledgeable evaluation of developments in authorities and truth test the claims being made.
Join our weekly politics publication, delivered each Friday all through the marketing campaign and past.
The brand new cupboard shall be confronted with an array of issues demanding speedy consideration. What one senior Labour official has reportedly dubbed Sue Gray’s “shit checklist” spans a number of authorities departments, from training to justice to infrastructure. these issues in flip, we would ask: is the social gathering over earlier than it’s even begun?
Tennessee Witney/Shutterstock
1. Thames Water
The UK’s largest water firm is in a deep monetary gap, with greater than £18 billion of debt, evaporating funding, and a long-running standoff between shareholders and the business regulator, Ofwat, over the paying of dividends. This, mixed with the appreciable funding required to overtake Thames Water’s creaking infrastructure, has put the corporate getting ready to collapse.
Ofwat is predicted to publish its plan for the water business on July 15, lower than two weeks into the brand new authorities’s first time period. The regulator is predicted to rule out permitting Thames Water to lift payments because it had deliberate to. If that’s the case, or if Ofwat insists that infrastructure pledges be met, then Starmer may properly have to think about an costly nationalisation of this water firm.
Learn extra:
How Thames Water got here to be flooded with debt – and what it means for taxpayers
2. Overcrowding in prisons
In accordance with the Jail Governors’ Affiliation (PGA), prisons in England and Wales are 99% full. With knock-on results for the courtroom system’s potential to listen to instances and move sentencing, the PGA warns that “your complete felony justice system stands on the precipice of failure”.
Labour has promised to reform the planning system so prisons are designated as websites of nationwide significance, which means it may construct extra of them. Nonetheless, it’ll nonetheless take years to yield the 20,000 further jail locations Labour has pledged. And even when this does occur, there isn’t any clear consensus that merely rising capability will resolve all the issues, with out equally resourcing the rehabilitative arm of the Jail Service.
The plain answer to creating extra capability within the quick time period is early releases. This could embrace prisoners nearing the tip of their sentences and people who are deemed of low threat to the general public. At the moment, judges are additionally being requested to think about their sentencing choices.
Learn extra:
How Iceland takes higher care of its international offenders than the remainder of Europe
3. Public sector pay negotiations
Given Labour’s historic hyperlinks with the main public sector commerce unions, together with Unite and Unison, public sector staff could also be hoping that the brand new authorities will counter 14 years of pay stagnation beneath the Conservatives.
Nonetheless, early on within the election cycle, it grew to become clear that some unions weren’t proud of Labour’s manifesto. Unite refused to endorse it and the brand new chancellor, Rachel Reeves, has made no effort to recommend cash will circulate extra freely whereas she heads up the Treasury.
With inflationary pressures easing and rates of interest predicted to fall by late summer season, some will argue that the case for pay rises is dissipating. But for others, lack of motion on pay shall be an admission that Britain’s way of life has slipped completely.
4. Universities going beneath
The monetary disaster in England’s universities has lengthy been brewing. Many are confronted with a precipitous collapse in abroad scholar numbers and an accompanying lack of revenue – an issue compounded by their general working loss when offering for dwelling college students.
House tuition charges have barely risen for the reason that £9,000 charge was launched in 2012 – whereas in actual phrases they’ve dropped by a 3rd. The £9,250 universities now obtain for every dwelling scholar compares badly with the precise value for instructing a scholar, which is calculated at £12,000.
Many universities are wrestling with excessive rates of interest and a slowdown within the property market, making loans taken out on capital investments more and more troublesome to pay. Some politicians have known as for home tuition charges to be raised. Nonetheless, as Nick Clegg and the Lib Dems can attest, tuition charges are one of many “third rails” of British politics – contact it and also you die.
Starmer is left with solely two practical choices: do away with the boundaries on worldwide scholar numbers, or considerably revisit the best way universities are funded – however once more, this may require throwing cash on the drawback. As with different facets of its manifesto, Labour has been imprecise on its proposals for greater training, maybe in an try to go away all choices on the desk.
Learn extra:
What occurs if a college goes bust?
5. NHS funding shortfall
The well being service at present has a finances shortfall of £12 billion. This displays a number of challenges – from remedies getting dearer and crumbling infrastructure to ballooning ready instances and disputes over pay.
Though Labour has seemingly recognised that funding is necessary, its manifesto refused to place a quantity on how a lot it will commit. As a substitute, the pledges had been accompanied by guarantees of modernisation and reform to enhance the service. The Institute for Fiscal Research estimates Labour’s pledges to be price £1.8 billion – manner in need of the required quantity.
The state of the NHS is a continuing litmus take a look at for any authorities, so addressing it will at all times be a prime precedence. Nonetheless, with meagre public funds, it is likely to be simpler mentioned than executed.
6. Failing native councils
Native authorities in England have been among the many worst affected by the Conservative programme of austerity. Eight have declared efficient chapter since 2018, and one in 5 say they might observe swimsuit with out intervention from central authorities.
Learn extra:
How 14 years of Conservative rule has made council chapter commonplace
To this point Labour, like the opposite events, has not mentioned the way it plans to deal with this, however Starmer can not afford to not. The extra councils go bankrupt, the extra individuals will wrestle to entry the essential on a regular basis techniques they depend on, that are funded by native authorities.
As with universities, there’s a sturdy case right here for reform. English native authorities is among the many most centralised within the western world, with tight restrictions on financing and budgets.
In the end, the UK is in an financial rut and most of the issues that may get the nation out of it require one factor: cash. Starmer has pledged fiscal self-discipline whereas additionally eschewing a return to austerity. There are clear contradictions to this strategy which imply that on the minute, the sums don’t add up.
