An olive oil war rages between Italy and Spain

“It will have been extra logical for a Spaniard to go to Italy to promote and never for an Italian to come back right here”.

Carrying a flowered shirt and horn-rimmed glasses, Leonardo D’Errico, an Italian who has lived in Spain because the Nineteen Nineties, appears to be like again over his profession surrounded by oil samples and looking trophies that adorn the partitions of his workplace in Torredonjimeno (Jaén, Andalusia). His story can also be the story of the olive oil commerce. It’s the story of a strong Italian trade that constructed an empire based mostly on mass manufacturing in Spain, a neighbour that has now overtaken it in international export markets.

He’s an oil dealer, an middleman who places merchants in touch with mills. Italy has at all times wanted oil to export, and Spain, which usually produces about half of the world’s olive oil, has a surplus. This imbalance has prompted a dependency whereby Italy buys, bottles underneath its personal manufacturers and sells again, at the next value, giant portions of Spanish oil. And it’s not precisely small fry (if you happen to pardon the pun). Italy has been the vacation spot of almost half of Spanish exports, the overwhelming majority of which it resells, not less than because the Nineteen Nineties.

However it’s a enterprise mannequin that’s changing into out of date: “Our work has began to decrease as a result of the massive Spanish teams have direct relations with the producers,” says D’Errico. In 2023, Italy accounted for less than 22% of Spain’s olive oil gross sales, a determine that was unthinkable a decade in the past, when it nonetheless accounted for 47%. The business chain has shortened and low cost bulk gross sales by way of Italy are giving technique to packaged oil of fine high quality and worth.

But regardless of this, the Spanish oil sector continues to talk Italian. Andalusia’s liquid gold is flooding worldwide markets, sure, however with names akin to Pompeian, Carapelli or Bertolli. “Made in Italy is untouchable”, warns Leonardo D’Errico.

40% of worldwide manufacturing 

With 283 million olive bushes, Spain dominates the worldwide olive oil market: within the 2021/22 season, the final one earlier than drought destroyed its harvest, it produced 44% of the world’s oil and accounted for 59% of worldwide gross sales, in accordance with the Worldwide Olive Oil Council. Italy, in the meantime, produced barely 10% and exported 20%, though with a nuance: its gross sales, regardless of being overwhelmingly of Spanish oil, have been 41% dearer, in accordance with Eurostat. The Spanish model is struggling to compete with the Italian one.

Carbonell got here up in opposition to this actuality within the early 2000s: the model landed in america with the Deoleo group – then referred to as SOS, based mostly in Córdoba – and got down to conquer a market that was clearly on the rise however, on the time, monopolised by Italy. It didn’t work. For Individuals, as for a lot of Europeans, olive oil is an Italian product.

The explanations for this affiliation are historic. Within the phrases of Teresa Pérez, Director of the Spanish Olive Oil Buying and selling Affiliation, “Spain was very properly positioned earlier than the Second World Battle and the dictatorship, nevertheless it was closed as a market and Italian immigration acted as an envoy for olive oil”. Spain’s isolation additionally coincided with the creation of the European Financial Group, which in 1957 liberalised commerce between its members and subsidised agricultural manufacturing, together with Italian olive groves. Spain in the meantime needed to pay tariffs to export to the remainder of Europe.

0il produced in Córdoba is marketed worldwide underneath names akin to Bertolli, Carapelli and Sasso, with out even passing by Italy

“He who strikes first strikes twice”, remarks Rafael Pico, Director Basic of the Spanish Olive Oil & Pomace Olive Oil Exporters’ Affiliation (ASOLIVA), a phrase recognisable throughout the sector. Italy arrived first and conquered the worldwide markets.

However its manufacturing has stagnated because the Nineteen Nineties and barely covers its home demand, so it was compelled to show to the Mediterranean basin to produce its export trade, which has tripled its gross sales within the final three a long time. And on this search, Spain is the supply of as much as 90% of its imports, together with different markets in Greece, Tunisia, Portugal, Turkey and Syria.

In distinction to Italy’s stagnation, Spanish manufacturing has tripled because the Nineteen Nineties. Entry into the European Financial Group in 1986 boosted the modernisation and competitiveness of its olive groves thanks to help from the Frequent Agricultural Coverage, but in addition its dedication to intensive and irrigated cultivation. Consequently, whereas beforehand lower than 100,000 hectares of olive groves have been irrigated in Spain, by 2023 there have been nearly 900,000, and manufacturing within the province of Jaén alone has exceeded that of the entire of Italy.

“Spain has performed a terrific job in agronomy and Italy has performed a terrific job in advertising. Now we have devoted ourselves to producing cheaply, to mechanising giant areas and to irrigation,” says Rafael Gutiérrez, Director of Bulk Operations on the Dcoop cooperative, the world’s main olive oil producer. Primarily based in Antequera (Málaga), his firm exports round half of what it produces, primarily in bulk to Italy. However Gutiérrez warns: “There are Italian names however not Italian manufacturers”.

Dcoop itself has gone from being only a provider of bulk oil to competing for its advertising overseas. To take action, it has Italianised its gross sales with the Pompeian model, based by Italian emigrants in 1906 in Baltimore: Dcoop partnered with Pompeian’s house owners in 2015 to promote Andalusian oil in america underneath their seal and has ended up changing into the main model with a market share of 20%. “Pompeian realised that it wanted stable manufacturing and now boasts 75,000 farmers in Andalusia behind it. It isn’t an Italian intermediary who buys from all around the world, and this has caught on in America”, explains its bulk gross sales supervisor.

One thing comparable was performed by Deoleo, the world’s largest olive oil bottler, which, though owned by the British funding fund CVC Capital Companions since 2014, maintains its headquarters in Spain. After the Carbonell fiasco, they modified their technique and pulled in large-scale liquidity to purchase the Italian manufacturers Minerva (2005), Friol (2006) and Bertolli (2008). Because of these acquisitions, oil produced in Córdoba is marketed worldwide underneath names akin to Bertolli, Carapelli and Sasso, with out even passing by Italy.

For Rafael Pérez, Deoleo’s High quality Director, his group has “turned the tables”. “We purchase between 70-90% of our oil in Spain, we use Italian manufacturers and distribute them to the remainder of the world”. By way of this, Spain has come to regulate the advertising world, and has taken benefit of its business pull to promote extra, albeit on the expense of the Spanish manufacturers themselves.

Thanks to those modifications, Spain has grow to be the undisputed chief in commerce exterior Europe since 2014 and in imports to america since 2016, which is already the second largest importer on the earth and can quickly grow to be the main shopper. In Mexico and Asia, rising markets through which it has competed on equal phrases with Italy, Spain virtually monopolises gross sales, whereas Deoleo (Córdoba), Dcoop (Málaga), Sovena (Seville), Migasa (Seville) and Acesur (Jaén) are the most important gamers in Spanish oil exports.

“This has not been achieved in a single day: income from the Spanish trade has been invested in rising olive plantations, higher industries and higher distribution within the markets. Now we have been capable of make investments, which the Italian sector has not,” argues Rafael Pico, Director of ASOLIVA.

Regardless of this, Italy continues to be the vacation spot for 1 / 4 of Spanish exports, one thing for which Pico blames farmers and cooperatives: “The philosophy of the trade is targeted on the margins and the model of the longer term to create a worth chain for the entire sector, however the farmers and cooperatives do not care, they solely take into consideration at the moment”.

Cristóbal Cano, Head of Olive Oil on the Small Farmers’ and Ranchers’ Union, defends the agricultural sector, saying that the farmers “do not really promote the oil”, however that it’s the Italians who come to purchase from the mills and use their “place of energy” to repair the value. And, he counters: “It’s these larger up within the trade that concentrate on the quick time period, benefiting from Italian manufacturers with out in search of a change that will profit our nation extra”.

Amount and high quality

With 1,842 mills and round 400,000 olive growers, the atomisation of the sector has been one of many main hindrances for the Spanish trade. On the different finish of the chain, nonetheless, giant Spanish supermarkets like Mercadona account for 3 quarters of gross sales and have a terrific capability to affect value setting at supply.

The manufacturing chain is constructed upon robust cooperatives, which account for round 70% of manufacturing, however the chain loses density with regards to the advertising sector, the other downside to Italy. For that reason, with a purpose to promote produce in numbers normally thrice larger than nationwide consumption, Spain is compelled to resort to bulk gross sales, which account for round two thirds of exports.

“Once you see the enterprise from the manufacturing facet you may see we’ve got an issue, as a result of we regularly have a lot oil that we don’t know what to do with it, so we find yourself virtually giving it away,” says Rafael Pérez of Deoleo. However, others, such because the Managing Director of the Seville cooperative Oleoestepa, Álvaro Olavarría, laud “the luck of getting a deficit market” such because the Italian one which covers Spain’s gross sales wants, though he prefers to diversify his enterprise: “Bulk is a commodity and to rely solely on it’s to place your self within the lap of the gods”.

Oleoestepa, which has 7,000 members and solely works with further virgin olive oil, has prioritised its bottling enterprise this yr – which is extra worthwhile – over its bulk enterprise as a result of lack of olives, so gross sales to Italy have been insignificant. However its Managing Director makes it clear: “If the climate is sweet, we are inclined to go to worldwide bulk markets akin to Italy”.

The dedication to high quality and personal model is replicated by Aires de Jaén, which exports between 60% and 70% of its harvest from Jabalquinto, solely in packaged codecs. For Ichun Lin, Export Supervisor for the Jaén firm, “your corporation is simply price as a lot as your model is price”, so you will need to “give causes for them to decide on you and inform a narrative behind the product”. “If you happen to solely promote in bulk, strategically you do not add worth. You must go for the packaged product identical to Italy did fifty years in the past,” says Lin.

However the battle for high quality will not be being received by the Spanish, as proven by the distinction in costs and the variety of designations of origin; Italy has twelve greater than Spain. The picual number of olive is the most typical in Spain and in addition probably the most celebrated and awarded on the earth, however whether it is harvested after October it acquires a flavour that isn’t normally appreciated overseas. But in Spain, many farmers depart the olives to ripen on the tree in search of a better yield.

“Spanish oil needs to be corrected with different sweeter oils. In Italy it’s usually mentioned that it tastes like cat piss and so they favor to purchase it in Greece”, says the middleman Leonardo D’Errico, who accuses Spanish producers of placing “kilos” earlier than high quality. Deoleo takes the identical line: “The typical high quality of Argentina and Chile is superior to that of Spain, and – in fact – so is Italy’s. We’re one step behind when it comes to high quality and we can’t afford to overlook the boat right here”.

In the direction of “Made in Spain”

Since 1990, olive oil consumption has doubled worldwide. Regardless of this, the liquid gold nonetheless accounts for simply 1% of worldwide vegetable oil consumption, which is dominated by palm, soybean, rapeseed and sunflower oil. The scope for progress is due to this fact huge.

The priority now’s provide, in accordance with Jaime Lillo, government director of the Worldwide Olive Council. The olive tree wants much less water than most crops, however “the massive query is how the Mediterranean basin goes to adapt to local weather change”. With more and more scarce and erratic rainfall, entry to water will probably be a key challenge for the competitiveness of olive groves, particularly in Spain, which is the European nation with the best proportion of its territory vulnerable to desertification, at 74%. In the meantime, 31% of its farms are already irrigated and olive groves proceed to unfold alongside the banks of the Guadalquivir.

The potential for olive oil manufacturing in Spain is 2.2 million tonnes, when taking into consideration the rise in plantations because the manufacturing peak of the 2018/19 season, when 1.8 million tonnes have been harvested. Regardless of this, not everybody appears to be like favourably on this situation. For Dcoop, actually, “the lean season will come when it rains”. A report harvest would knock down gross sales costs and power them to resort to bulk gross sales and Italian re-exports.

In the meantime, Italian farmers are crying out in opposition to the “iberisation” of their olive manufacturing, railing in opposition to Spain’s “super-intensive, single-variety” mannequin. The battle for numbers has lengthy since been misplaced, however Italy stays high canine in advertising and has clung to the standard of its restricted harvest.

The oil wars, removed from being historical past, are intensifying because the enterprise grows and the challenges improve. For now, the Spanish model continues to observe the Made in Italy’s lead.

👉 Authentic article on El Orden Mundial