A Full Implementation of the Israel-Hamas Ceasefire is Uncertain — Global Issues

by Oritro Karim (united nations)Monday, February 17, 2025Inter Press Service

UNITED NATIONS, Feb 17 (IPS) – On January 19, Israel and Hamas applied a ceasefire settlement that will finish the preventing in Israel and Palestine, see the return of hostages and prisoners, and start a interval of restoration and reconstruction for Palestine. Though the previous a number of weeks have seen a comparatively clean transition and a cessation of hostilities, the prospect of a long-term implementation of the ceasefire stays fragile and there’s important threat of a return to warfare and heightened instability throughout the Center East. With the humanitarian state of affairs in Gaza enhancing for the primary time in 16 months, it’s crucial that the ceasefire stays in impact.

On February 13, Hamas reiterated that it will launch hostages as scheduled within the ceasefire settlement. This got here after Hamas knowledgeable reporters that it will delay the discharge of Israeli hostages as a consequence of Israel’s blocking of humanitarian help and returning displaced Palestinians to the fallacious areas. The primary section of the ceasefire is predicted to final 42 days, with Hamas having incrementally launched 16 of the 33 hostages.

Later that day, David Mencer, a spokesperson for the Israeli authorities, knowledgeable reporters that the ceasefire can be referred to as off if Hamas didn’t launch three hostages by midday on Saturday.

“We’re speaking about these Israeli hostages arriving again in Israel. If that doesn’t occur by Saturday, midday, the ceasefire will finish and the IDF will resume intense navy operations till Hamas is absolutely defeated,” mentioned Mencer.

U.S. President Donald Trump acknowledged that “all hell goes to interrupt out”, indicating militaristically aggressive penalties for Palestine if the hostages weren’t returned by midday. He additionally proposed plans to take away Palestinians from the enclave. The feedback made by the U.S. and Israeli governments have elicited a lot concern among the many worldwide neighborhood on the long-term efficacy of the ceasefire and if a three-phase implementation is possible.

Raed Jarrar, the Advocacy Director of Democracy of DAWN, opines that these plans aren’t viable. “ If the world have been to undergo President Trump’s plan, there can be far reaching implications for each nation, which nobody desires. President Trump exhibits that most strain doesn’t work. All it did was pressure Netanyahu to uphold the phrases of the ceasefire”, Jarrar informed IPS.

In line with a state of affairs replace from the Workplace for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), presently, 76 Israeli residents and extra international captives stay in Gaza, together with plenty of deceased hostages. Figures from the Israel Jail Service (IPS) point out that there are roughly 9,846 Palestinians in Israeli custody, together with 1,734 prisoners, 2,941 remand detainees, and 1,802 hostages who’re described as “illegal combatants”. This doesn’t account for the Palestinians who’ve been within the custody of the Israeli navy following October 7, 2023.

United Nations (UN) Secretary-Common António Guterres has indicated that it’s crucial that each events stay devoted to fulfilling their duties as a return to struggle would drastically exacerbate the dire humanitarian disaster in Gaza.

“We should keep away from in any respect prices the resumption of hostilities in Gaza that will result in an immense tragedy,” mentioned Guterres. “I attraction to Hamas to proceed with the deliberate liberation of hostages subsequent Saturday. Either side should absolutely abide by their commitments within the ceasefire settlement and resume severe negotiations in Doha for the second section.”

On February 12, SARI International, a corporation that analyzed traits in geopolitical relations, launched a report detailing the attainable penalties of a return to hostilities between the 2 events. They predict that the ceasefire will probably fall by means of as a consequence of rising frustration between Israel, Palestine, the U.S., and Saudi Arabia, all of whom have totally different visions of what the way forward for Palestine ought to appear to be. Moreover, it’s speculated that within the subsequent few weeks, Hamas might refuse to launch extra hostages, resulting in a “resumption of focused Israeli navy operations, together with sporadic airstrikes”.

The report additionally states {that a} rise in geopolitical tensions within the Center East, which incorporates pro-Palestinian protests in Egypt, Jordan, and Lebanon, might provoke Israel and Hamas to take motion that will successfully finish the ceasefire.

In line with the UN, over two million individuals in Gaza are absolutely depending on humanitarian help for fundamental companies. “Situations in Gaza are dire. Palestinians handled intensive brutality for sixteen months. Israel has violated the phrases of settlement and blocked gasoline, meals, and demanding assets”, mentioned Jarrar.

Nevertheless, the ceasefire will probably undergo to Part 2. “As soon as a ceasefire goes into impact, it’s tough to cease. Israel desires their hostages again so it’s of their greatest curiosity to proceed,” mentioned Jarrar. He added that Part 3 is unsure as a result of as soon as all prisoners are exchanged, Israel may renege on its obligations and proceed hostilities in Gaza.

Some political analysts have additionally expressed skepticism on the long-term feasibility of the ceasefire as a consequence of the potential of a tough transition from one section to a different.

“The transition from section one of many deal to the subsequent ones might be a problem, as Netanyahu and his far-right coalition oppose a proper finish to the struggle and a full Israeli withdrawal from the Gaza Strip…Ending the struggle must also be leveraged to advancing an Israeli-Palestinian two-state resolution. However this, too, is rejected by the present Israeli authorities, and necessitates management change in Israel,” mentioned Nimrod Goren, the President and founding father of Mitvim- The Israeli Institute for Regional Overseas Insurance policies.

Contrasting pursuits between the 2 states additionally threatens to unravel the ceasefire. For instance, using the United Nations Reduction and Works Company for Palestinian Refugees (UNRWA) to rebuild Palestine and supply help, has been extensively contested as a consequence of Israel’s long-standing disdain for the group. Moreover, it’s probably that Israel might reject a two-state resolution.

“If the third section of the ceasefire settlement is ever reached, essentially the most crucial challenge might be on the negotiators’ desk: the reconstruction and, subsequently, the administration of the Gaza Strip…The Prime Minister of the Palestinian Authority (PA), Mohammed Mustafa of Fatah, declared yesterday that the Palestinian Authority (PA) alone ought to handle the Strip within the post-war interval. Nevertheless, when they’re confronted with a lot destruction on the bottom, and if there’s real UN mediation, it can then be mandatory for the 2 sides to discover a modus vivendi,” mentioned Caterina Roggero, a Senior Affiliate Analysis Fellow on the Institute for Worldwide Political Research (ISPI).

In line with the SARI International report, if the ceasefire have been to unravel, there can be ripple results all through the Center East. Regional instability can be heightened, with the almost definitely ramification being an eruption in hostilities between Yemen and Israel. The Islamist political motion in Yemen, Houthis, would probably resume their assaults in Israel within the Crimson Sea. Political protests within the Center East would develop stronger and stoke dissidence and insecurity.

Moreover, the humanitarian state of affairs in Gaza would quickly deteriorate if hostilities have been to proceed. If humanitarian help was shut off from getting into the enclave, famine, illness, and hunger would proceed to ravage the inhabitants.

“It is a super concern if the ceasefire doesn’t final. You noticed the struggling that had occurred from October 2023 up till only a few weeks in the past, and we don’t wish to return to that. All efforts should be made to guarantee that this ceasefire, which has been treasured to the individuals of the area and certainly of the broader Center East, that ceasefire is maintained,” mentioned Farhan Haq, the Deputy Spokesperson for the Secretary-Common of the UN.

On February 16, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio was in Israel and met with Netanyahu, the place they held discussions on a number of points together with the ceasefire. Throughout a joint press convention, Netanyahu shared that he and Trump are “working in full cooperation and coordination” over a typical technique.

He added: “We will’t at all times share the small print of this technique with the general public, together with when the gates of hell might be opened, as they absolutely will, if all our hostages aren’t launched till the final one in every of them.”

Rubio mentioned that President Trump has been “very daring about his view on what Gaza ought to be”. He additionally remarked that Hamas “can’t proceed as a navy or a authorities pressure”, and that “so long as it stands as a pressure that may govern…that may threaten by use of violence, peace turns into unimaginable.”

IPS UN Bureau Report

Observe @IPSNewsUNBureauFollow IPS Information UN Bureau on Instagram

© Inter Press Service (2025) — All Rights Reserved. Unique supply: Inter Press Service

The place subsequent?

Hyperlink to this web page out of your web site/weblog

Add the next HTML code to your web page:

<p><a href=”https://www.globalissues.org/information/2025/02/17/39101″>A Full Implementation of the Israel-Hamas Ceasefire is Unsure</a>, <cite>Inter Press Service</cite>, Monday, February 17, 2025 (posted by International Points)</p>

… to supply this:

A Full Implementation of the Israel-Hamas Ceasefire is Unsure, Inter Press Service, Monday, February 17, 2025 (posted by International Points)