European leaders are scrambling to answer what seems like the tip of dependable US safety of the continent.
It’s unclear what the “most important European international locations” (which incorporates the UK) may be capable of agree at a unexpectedly convened assembly in Paris on Monday February 17. However particular person international locations, together with the UK and Germany, have come ahead to place concrete presents on the desk for Ukraine’s safety, which might embody placing their troops on the bottom.
This uncommon circling of the wagons was triggered by the 2025 Munich Safety Convention, which ended the day before today. It delivered to a detailed per week of exceptional upheaval for Europe, leaving little question that two already apparent developments within the deteriorating transatlantic relationship accelerated additional.
What the world noticed was unabashed US unilateralism on the subject of the struggle in Ukraine. Ominously, there was additionally a transparent indication of the extent of American intentions to intrude within the home political processes of European international locations – most notably the upcoming German parliamentary elections on February 23.
None of this could have come as a shock. However the full-force assault by Donald Trump’s envoys to Europe was nonetheless sobering – particularly as soon as all its implications are thought of. What was, maybe, extra shocking was that European leaders pushed again and did so in an unusually public and unequivocal approach.
Over the course of just some days, two of the worst European fears had been confirmed. First, the Trump administration is pushing forward with its concept of a US-Russia deal to finish the struggle in Ukraine. And all of the indicators are that Washington plans to go away Ukraine and the EU out of any negotiations and to their very own units on the subject of post-ceasefire safety preparations.
On February 12, the US president introduced he had spoken at size with Russian president Vladimir Putin, and subsequently knowledgeable Ukraine’s president Volodymyr Zelensky of the dialog. The identical day, US defence secretary Pete Hegseth, confirmed at a press convention after a gathering of Nato defence ministers in Brussels that direct negotiations between Russia and the US would start instantly. They won’t embody any European or Ukrainian officers, he mentioned.
Hegseth additionally poured chilly water on any hopes that there could be strong US safety ensures for Ukraine. He explicitly dominated out US troops for any peacekeeping forces deployed by different Nato members, or that any assault on these forces could be thought of an assault on the entire alliance below article 5 of the Nato treaty.
The European response was swift and, a minimum of on paper, decisive. Proper after Hegseth’s feedback in Brussels, the Weimar+ group (Germany, France, Poland + Italy, Spain, the UK, the EU’s diplomatic service and the European Fee) issued a joint assertion reiterating their dedication to enhanced help in defence of Ukraine’s independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity.
On February 14, the EU’s prime officers – European council president António Costa and European Fee president Ursula von der Leyen – met with Zelensky on the margins of the convention. They assured him of the EU’s “continued and secure help to Ukraine till a simply, complete and lasting peace is reached”.
The next day, Costa’s speech in Munich reiterated this dedication. Just like earlier feedback by Nato’s secretary basic, Mark Rutte, Costa underlined Europe’s willpower to “to behave higher, stronger and quicker in constructing the Europe of defence”.
However these declarations of the EU’s willpower to proceed supporting Ukraine don’t replicate consensus contained in the Union on such a place. Weimar+ solely features a choose variety of EU member states, establishments and the UK, underlining the persevering with difficulties in reaching unanimity on vital safety and defence points. Unsurprisingly, Hungary’s prime minister, Viktor Orbán, issued a scathing condemnation of the Weimar+ assertion as a “unhappy testomony of unhealthy Brusselian management”.
Orbán’s feedback play proper into many Europeans’ fears about one other darkish aspect of Trump’s agenda on the subject of transatlantic relations. As foreshadowed within the influential Undertaking 2025 report by a coalition of conservative US thinktanks, the Trump administration is intent on weakening European unity. It will embody stopping the UK from slipping “again into the orbit of the EU” and “creating new allies contained in the EU – particularly the Central European international locations”.
Opening up divides
The US vice-president, J.D. Vance, used his speech in Munich to assert that the true menace to European safety was not coming from Russia or China, however relatively “from inside”. He went on to chide “EU commissars” and insinuated that Europe’s present leaders had extra in frequent with the “tyrannical forces on this continent” who misplaced the chilly struggle.
In Romania, the place presidential elections had been cancelled after proof of huge Russian election interference emerged, opposition events revelled in Vance’s feedback that the transfer had been primarily based on the “flimsy suspicions of an intelligence company and massive strain from its continental neighbours”. The vice-president has additional exacerbated political divisions in a key European and Nato ally proper on the border with Ukraine.
Vance subsequently sought out Alice Weidel, the co-leader of the right-wing Different for Germany (AfD). The pair reportedly mentioned the struggle in Ukraine, German home politics and the so-called brandmauer. That is the settlement between centre-right and left-wing events in Germany to type a “firewall” to stop excessive right-wing events from becoming a member of coalitions, which has just lately been weakened.
Their assembly was broadly criticised as yet one more American try for the celebration to spice up its probabilities at Germany’s upcoming parliamentary elections on February 23. Referring to Germany’s historic expertise with Nazism, the German chancellor, Olaf Scholz defended the necessity to maintain the road in opposition to far-right political events just like the AfD.
Polar shift
There have been many watershed moments and wake-up requires Europe previously. What’s completely different now could be {that a} new multipolar order is rising – and Europe just isn’t certainly one of its poles. Equally importantly, given the willpower of this US administration to upend the prevailing worldwide order, Europe just isn’t part of any pole anymore both.
Concurrently at stake are European unity and the transatlantic relationship. These are the 2 key pillars which have ensured European safety, democracy and prosperity because the finish of the second world struggle. Out of necessity, Europe will more than likely have to regulate to a much-weakened transatlantic relationship. However the European challenge is not going to survive with out unity.
It is a vital juncture for Europe. The continent must outline its future place and position within the dysfunctional love triangle of Trump, Putin and Xi, a triumvirate that may form and dominate the brand new world order.
Stefan Wolff, Professor of Worldwide Safety, College of Birmingham
This text is republished from The Dialog below a Artistic Commons license. Learn the unique article.
