https://sputnikglobe.com/20240524/inter-eu-spat-over-air-defenses-scratches-the-surface-of-deep-divisions-in-europe-1118618394.html
Inter-EU Spat Over Air Defenses Scratches the Floor of Deep Divisions in Europe
Inter-EU Spat Over Air Defenses Scratches the Floor of Deep Divisions in Europe
Sputnik Worldwide
Poland and Greece on one facet and EU behemoth Germany on the opposite have introduced competing visions of a standard European air protection system. Sputnik requested revered Polish political observer Mateusz Piskorski concerning the hidden tectonic political, financial and geostrategic tensions that the rival plans have laid naked.
2024-05-24T18:51+0000
2024-05-24T18:51+0000
2024-05-24T18:57+0000
evaluation
mateusz piskorski
europe
donald tusk
kyriakos mitsotakis
poland
france
greece
european union (eu)
european parliament
https://cdn1.img.sputnikglobe.com/img/07e8/05/18/1118618863_0:22:601:360_1920x0_80_0_0_39c6284fa993260bca52b47daac4e89f.jpg
Warsaw and Athens on Thursday urged the European Union to hitch forces to create a standard “air protection defend” for the bloc.The ‘defend’ “have to be a program which addresses [the] main vulnerability in our safety” ensuing from an array of world crises, and one “which strengthens the EU’s general protection capabilities and incentivizes European protection firms to develop cutting-edge applied sciences,” the letter careworn.Von der Leyen, up for reelection within the shortly approaching elections to the European Parliament in June, shortly endorsed the Polish-Greek proposal at a debate Thursday night time.The brand new air protection proposals comes after –and apparently as a direct problem to, a German-led initiative floated in 2022 to create a ‘European Sky Protect’, involving the joint European buy of dear air protection gear. That venture fell into obscurity after different main EU companions, together with France, expressed opposition to buying weapons made outdoors the bloc.France and Italy have been pushing their very own refined rival to the American Patriot missile system often known as the SAMP/T – priced at roughly $500 million per battery and $2 million per interceptor missile (in comparison with about $1 billion per battery and $4 million per missile within the Patriot’s case). Each programs have been thrashed by Russian forces after being despatched to Ukraine.The competing EU air protection proposals and incapability to agree on a bloc-wide coverage to this point is logical consequence of a union divided by inside political divisions, financial and strategic issues, and the overbearing affect of Europe’s companions in Washington, says Mateusz Piskorski, a former Sjem lawmaker, unbiased political observer and columnist for the Mysl Polska (‘Polish Thought’) newspaper.Piskorski reminded Sputnik that the second of the competing air protection proposals have been unveiled on the eve of elections to the European Parliament, and recalled that each the Polish and Greek prime ministers are members of the identical European-level get together – the center-right, pro-Europeanist European Individuals’s Get together.From that perspective, the observer careworn that there’s no query that the Polish-Greek ‘European Air Protection Protect’ is a substitute for the German European Sky Protect proposal, recalling that Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s Social Democrats are direct rivals to the European Individuals’s Get together on the EU degree.Poland too has “historic and political grounds” of its personal to specific skepticism of German initiatives, Piskorski mentioned.One of many prime causes Europe already doesn’t have its personal widespread air protection system comes all the way down to the affect of its “Anglo-Saxon pals, and, naturally, firstly the USA, who’re defending their very own pursuits and see continental Europe as their protectorate,” Piskorski mentioned.The UK performs second fiddle on this association, having left the EU by means of Brexit, closing the door to any pan-European integration initiatives, together with protection coverage.With Central European international locations like Poland owing their allegiance to the US, Piskorski guidelines out the creation a genuinely European mutual air protection association on the present stage. “Nobody will say so instantly, however such an initiative wouldn’t be acquired kindly by Washington and American authorities, similar to makes an attempt to create a standard European protection coverage,” he mentioned.That mentioned, the observer doesn’t rule out a European transfer towards “strategic autonomy,” to cite President Macron of France, together with so far as questions associated to protection are involved, after the presidential elections within the US, and within the occasion that Washington scales again its participation in and financing for numerous defense-related initiatives in Europe.Discord in EuropeBesides US intransigence, as much as and together with the potential use of brokers of affect to withstand EU air protection initiatives, there are problems with financing, in addition to “technological boundaries,” the observer believes.As for technological boundaries, “they’re linked, to begin with, with the truth that Europe has relied solely on the USA on this regard prior to now, and didn’t have time to develop its personal applied sciences to the identical degree…And naturally, inside Europe there may be competitors between the defense-industrial complexes of various nations. Naturally, any EU nation will search to assist the pursuits of its personal producers, builders of expertise, and so forth,” the political observer summed up.
https://sputnikglobe.com/20240513/are-nato-members-testing-the-waters-for-no-fly-zone-over-ukraine-1118413765.html
https://sputnikglobe.com/20240423/greek-god-of-fire-what-we-know-about-russias-s-500-prometheus-missile-system-1118074871.html
https://sputnikglobe.com/20240418/european-sky-shield-initiative-what-is-it-and-who-might-benefit-from-it-1117994218.html
https://sputnikglobe.com/20240418/unscrambling-the-polish-puzzle-warsaw-debates-european-sky-shield-membership-1117991578.html
poland
france
greece
Sputnik Worldwide
suggestions@sputniknews.com
+74956456601
MIA „Rosiya Segodnya“
2024
Information
en_EN
Sputnik Worldwide
suggestions@sputniknews.com
+74956456601
MIA „Rosiya Segodnya“
https://cdn1.img.sputnikglobe.com/img/07e8/05/18/1118618863_0:0:481:360_1920x0_80_0_0_2d13b9f0743b7f3947ddbe9a483681e5.jpg
Sputnik Worldwide
suggestions@sputniknews.com
+74956456601
MIA „Rosiya Segodnya“
why are there two competing european air protection initiatives, why are poland, greece and germany providing their very own european air protection proposals
why are there two competing european air protection initiatives, why are poland, greece and germany providing their very own european air protection proposals
Poland and Greece on one facet and EU behemoth Germany on the opposite have introduced competing visions of a standard European air protection system. Sputnik requested revered Polish political observer Mateusz Piskorski concerning the hidden tectonic political, financial and geostrategic tensions that the rival plans have laid naked.
Warsaw and Athens on Thursday urged the European Union to hitch forces to create a standard “air protection defend” for the bloc.
📃 ANNOUNCEMENT | Letter from the Prime Ministers of Poland and Greece to the President of the European Fee. “The European Union wants a sport changer, a daring initiative that can ship a transparent and robust message to our pals and foes, to our allies and rivals alike,… pic.twitter.com/t507WtMaBt
— Chancellery of the Prime Minister of Poland (@PremierRP_en) Could 23, 2024
The ‘defend’ “have to be a program which addresses [the] main vulnerability in our safety” ensuing from an array of world crises, and one “which strengthens the EU’s general protection capabilities and incentivizes European protection firms to develop cutting-edge applied sciences,” the letter careworn.
The brand new air protection proposals comes after –and apparently as a direct problem to, a German-led initiative floated in 2022 to create a ‘European Sky Protect’, involving the joint European buy of dear air protection gear. That venture fell into obscurity after different main EU companions, together with France, expressed opposition to buying weapons made outdoors the bloc.
Piskorski reminded Sputnik that the second of the competing air protection proposals have been unveiled on the eve of elections to the European Parliament, and recalled that each the Polish and Greek prime ministers are members of the identical European-level get together – the center-right, pro-Europeanist European Individuals’s Get together.
“As representatives of this pan-European get together, the ranks of which by the way embody Ursula von der Leyen, they’re possible attempting to exhibit within the framework of pre-election actions that they’ve their very own model and imaginative and prescient of a European air protection system. In different phrases, that is an election marketing campaign problem,” Piskorski defined.
From that perspective, the observer careworn that there’s no query that the Polish-Greek ‘European Air Protection Protect’ is a substitute for the German European Sky Protect proposal, recalling that Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s Social Democrats are direct rivals to the European Individuals’s Get together on the EU degree.
“Secondly, in fact, there are specific political subtleties,” Piskorski mentioned, pointing to lingering Greek animosities to Germany’s remedy of Athens a decade-and-a-half in the past when Greece suffered financial collapse, and the strict austerity packages enforced on it at Berlin’s path.
“Everybody understands that the creation of such a system – the event of this program would require the trouble of all EU members,” and {that a} main European energy – Germany or France, must take the lead, the observer famous.
One of many prime causes Europe already doesn’t have its personal widespread air protection system comes all the way down to the affect of its “Anglo-Saxon pals, and, naturally, firstly the USA, who’re defending their very own pursuits and see continental Europe as their protectorate,” Piskorski mentioned.
The UK performs second fiddle on this association, having left the EU by means of Brexit, closing the door to any pan-European integration initiatives, together with protection coverage.
With Central European international locations like Poland owing their allegiance to the US, Piskorski guidelines out the creation a genuinely European mutual air protection association on the present stage. “Nobody will say so instantly, however such an initiative wouldn’t be acquired kindly by Washington and American authorities, similar to makes an attempt to create a standard European protection coverage,” he mentioned.
“Makes an attempt to create massive, highly effective buildings within the military-industrial advanced of continental Europe are initiatives which contradict the principle financial and geopolitical pursuits of the USA,” Piskorski careworn.
“This might make these initiatives extra concrete and substantive. However this can be a query for the longer term. It’s a gradual course of. I feel that the method of gaining autonomy on this space could take not less than a number of years, maybe a number of a long time,” Piskorski careworn.
Moreover US intransigence, as much as and together with the potential use of brokers of affect to withstand EU air protection initiatives, there are problems with financing, in addition to “technological boundaries,” the observer believes.
“There are numerous elements right here, however firstly of all is the query of financing. We all know that, sadly, the European Fee’s sanctions coverage and the so-called ‘inexperienced agenda’ on environmental points, amongst different issues, has resulted in European business being curtailed. Europe is in a reasonably deep financial disaster, not less than for now,” Piskorski mentioned.
As for technological boundaries, “they’re linked, to begin with, with the truth that Europe has relied solely on the USA on this regard prior to now, and didn’t have time to develop its personal applied sciences to the identical degree…And naturally, inside Europe there may be competitors between the defense-industrial complexes of various nations. Naturally, any EU nation will search to assist the pursuits of its personal producers, builders of expertise, and so forth,” the political observer summed up.
