On the determination listening to of the case held at Diyarbakır eighth Excessive Legal Court docket on December 28, 2024, a 944-page justification of the jail sentence was given for the detained defendants mom Yüksel, brother Enes and uncle Salim Güran, and Nevzat Bahtiyar, who confessed that he hid Narin's lifeless physique within the Sıratutmaz Creek. The choice was written.
Within the reasoned determination, the statements of the defendants and witnesses throughout the trial part had been included.
Within the analysis a part of the choice, the next was famous:
“The truth that the defendants Enes, Salim and Yüksel Güran had been of their home, barn or annexe throughout the time interval when Narin was killed, and that is confirmed by the Nationwide Legal Court docket, narrowed base information, digital camera data, evaluation report and all different proof, can’t be clearly decided by our court docket.” The act of killing Narin was began by the defendant or defendants of their home, barn or extensions, after which Narin's physique was carried to the home, the place the act of killing was accomplished by the defendants Enes, Yüksel and Salim. Whereas it was anticipated that every one three defendants might have saved Narin from demise with a medical intervention of their home, secure or annexes, this intervention was not made they usually consented to Narin's demise. Furthermore, Yüksel was the mom of the sufferer, Salim was his uncle and Enes was his brother. Whereas the defendants had a authorized obligation to repel and forestall assaults, evil or different adverse actions towards the sufferer, they didn’t fulfill them and took part within the demise of Narin by not stopping the one that initiated the act of killing. It was decided that they participated.”
Within the determination, it was recorded that the defendants determined what to do by performing in unity and motion relating to the actions, behaviors and discourses they might take upon the demise incident after Narin's physique was introduced residence and the act of demise occurred. They gave Narin's lifeless physique to Nevzat Bahtiyar, who was close to the scene of the crime, and threw him into the stream. It was reported that they acted collectively in hiding and destroying the physique by asking him to bury it.
Within the determination, which acknowledged that the defendants acted and acted in a fashion that indicated that they’d no data of the demise incident, the next evaluations had been made:
“Once more, when Narin's lifeless physique was given to Nevzat, Yüksel and Enes, who had been at residence, had been the one ones in the home with Salim and the opposite doorways had been closed, agreed with Salim on this concern and waited behind closed doorways, the defendant Salim stated that the true objective of the killing was It was determined collectively by the opposite defendants to inform Nevzat that he killed Narin as a result of he noticed her relationship with Yüksel, and on this means they tried to cover the true objective, Narin's lifeless physique was taken by Nevzat and he acknowledged that he noticed Yüksel and crying whereas leaving the scene, subsequently, whereas Narin's lifeless physique was given to defendant Nevzat by defendant Salim, the opposite defendants had been conscious of the incident, and all 3 defendants had been knowledgeable about their roles within the fee of the crime and their very own actions. The opposite defendants accomplished their actions and established joint management over the fee of the crime along with the opposite defendants, on this context, the defendants had been in time and area unity till the top of the incident and the defendants acted as contributors. It has been accepted by our court docket that Salim, Enes and Yüksel Güran precipitated the demise of Narin Güran in cooperation with their concepts and actions. “Contemplating all these narratives, it has been understood that the homicide of Narin was carried out and accomplished by all 3 defendants collectively.”
In its unanimous determination on the listening to on December 28, 2024, the court docket board sentenced the detained defendants, mom Yüksel, older brother Enes and uncle Salim Güran, to aggravated life imprisonment for the crime of “intentional homicide towards the kid within the occasion of participation”, and to those that confessed to hiding Narin's lifeless physique within the Öncetutmaz Creek. Nevzat Bahtiyar was additionally sentenced to 4 years and 6 months in jail for “destroying, concealing or altering prison proof”. and determined to proceed his detention.
“3 defendants consented to demise when there was a chance of saving”
“It has been accepted by our Court docket that Salim Güran, Enes Güran and Yüksel Güran precipitated the demise of the deceased Narin Güran in cooperation with their concepts and actions. Contemplating all these narratives, it has been understood that the homicide of the sufferer Narin was carried out and accomplished by all 3 defendants collectively.
