The damning statistics that reveal the true cost of Brexit, five years on

It has been 5 years since Brexit “acquired executed” – and voters and politicians alike are nonetheless counting the associated fee.

Britons voted to depart the European Union by 52 per cent to 48 per cent in 2016, in a uncommon referendum that triggered the resignation of prime minister David Cameron. The UK then formally withdrew from the European Union on 31 January 2020, adopted by a transition interval that lasted till January 2021.

Brexiteers promised a brand new age of British sovereignty, a crackdown on migration and the much-derided “£350m per week” that may very well be diverted from the EU again into the NHS.

However half a decade on, and by many metrics, Brexit seems to have missed the mark.

The price of Brexit continues to be being decided, however the authorities watchdog estimates that the economic system will take a 15 per cent hit to commerce in the long run, whereas specialists recommend that the UK has suffered £100bn in misplaced output annually.

Since Britain left the EU, migration has been on the highest ranges since information started; whereas key sectors face staffing shortages.

And nearly six in 10 Britons (59 per cent) assume that Brexit has gone pretty or very badly, with simply 12 per cent believing it has gone effectively, in response to a YouGov ballot in October.

UK commerce knowledgeable David Henig advised The Impartial: ”The UK now has vital commerce limitations to its neighbours. It’s one thing we should dwell with. We won’t be allowed to overlook it; there’ll all the time be points.”

Brexit-optimist economist Julian Jessop, a fellow on the Institute of Financial Affairs, admitted that Brexit has made it more durable or “not possible” for small companies to regulate.

“The UK’s departure from the EU has undoubtedly had some unfavourable results on the economic system, notably via reductions in commerce, shortfalls in enterprise funding, and disruption to labour markets,” he advised The Impartial.

Nonetheless, he added that the “general drag on exports and imports has been a lot smaller than feared”.

Former deputy prime minister Lord Heseltine mentioned that almost 5 years on, Brexit “has been a historic catastrophe”.

“It has destroyed Britain’s management in Europe simply at a time when there was a essential want (for it), it has closed off alternatives for the youthful era to share in the advantages of Europe and it has denied Britain’s industrial base entry to the analysis and insurance policies of Europe. Our economic system is way worse due to it and there’s no respected authority that denies this.

“I feel the British individuals know that they have been deceived and the deceit is measured in diminished dwelling requirements,” he added.

Beneath, we have a look at how the numbers stack up.

A pricey divorce

The most recent Treasury estimates present that the price of Britain’s settlement with the EU stands at roughly £30.2bn in complete. That is separate from any estimates of misplaced cash from separating from the EU.

As of the beginning of 2024, the majority of this settlement (£23.8bn) had already been paid. Roughly £6.4bn nonetheless remained to be paid out to the EU in 2024 and onwards.

The federal government has not but printed the determine to the tip of 2024.

​Nonetheless, this price is hardly akin to the forecasted losses from exiting the EU by way of GDP and commerce.

A authorities spokesperson mentioned: “It can be crucial that we glance ahead, not backwards, that we don’t reopen the Brexit divides, and that we make Brexit work for the British individuals.

“That’s the reason we’re resetting the connection with our European pals to strengthen ties, safe a broad-based safety pact and deal with limitations to commerce.”

However commerce knowledgeable Mr Henig advised The Impartial that Brexit isn’t but behind us: “I’m afraid the story of Brexit carries on. The problems aren’t going away. We will’t go away all of it prior to now.”

So, what’s the actual price of Brexit to this point?

Britain’s exit from the EU coincided with the outbreak of the coronavirus pandemic and lockdowns, from March 2020, which impacted economies globally.

IEA economist Mr Jessop mentioned that it’s nonetheless too quickly to guage the long-term prices or advantages of Brexit, including: “On the combination degree, it’s not possible to separate out the influence of Brexit from different shocks, notably the pandemic and the vitality disaster. For what it’s value, my very own guess is that the UK economic system is now about one per cent smaller than it could in any other case have been.”

Even so, the UK’s GDP took the worst hit in comparison with all different G7 nations on the time; a ten.3 per cent drop in 2020.

In 2023, Bloomberg Economics estimated that the UK is struggling £100bn a yr in misplaced output from leaving the EU.

The economists Ana Andrade and Dan Hanson wrote that the UK dedicated “an act of financial self-harm when it voted to depart the EU”, with GDP 4 per cent smaller than it could have been with out Brexit.

In its newest forecasts alongside the brand new 2024 Price range, the Workplace for Price range Duty (OBR) estimated that UK commerce will take a 15 per cent hit in the long run on account of Brexit.

The unbiased monetary watchdog pointed to “weak progress in imports and exports over the medium time period [which] partly displays the persevering with influence of Brexit”.

Sir Nick Harvey, the CEO of pro-EU assume tank European Motion UK, is asking for a more in-depth partnership with Europe to restore a number of the financial harm from Brexit.

“Being out of the European single market has now dented the British economic system by greater than 5 per cent, inflicting an annual shortfall in Treasury funds of virtually £45bn. That equates to round a 3rd of the essential fee revenue tax yield,” he advised The Impartial.

“Our future prosperity and safety demand a a lot nearer partnership with Europe. The federal government’s ‘reset’ factors in the suitable path, however they should go a lot additional and far sooner if we’re to construct a brighter future.”

The influence on commerce

A current research from the Centre for Financial Efficiency at LSE discovered that items exports from the UK dropped by £27bn in 2022 alone on account of Brexit.

Particularly, the research concludes that the UK’s commerce cooperation settlement (TCA), applied in January 2021, diminished UK items exports (excluding companies) worldwide by 6.4 per cent as a consequence of a 13.2 per cent fall in EU exports.

The paper’s authors mentioned that the drop in EU commerce post-Brexit was as a result of “introduction of recent commerce limitations underneath the TCA, reasonably than the uncertainty of the withdrawal course of”.

The research means that 16,400 companies – some 14 per cent of UK exporters – stopped exporting to the EU as a consequence of Brexit commerce guidelines.

Although Thomas Sampson, co-author and LSE economics professor, says that the hit to commerce was “lower than anticipated”, he additionally referred to as the TCA a “catastrophe for small exporters”.

A part of that is possible as a result of elevated complexity of recent export laws, which bigger companies are higher geared up to soak up. Marks & Spencer’s chair has mentioned that the retailer has needed to hire a warehouse simply to retailer paperwork.

Mr Henig, director of the UK Commerce Coverage Challenge, mentioned that figures present Britain has suffered greater than the EU from the loss in commerce.

“Brexit has negatively affected our exports, greater than our imports from the EU. It’s been simpler for European importers to search out alternate suppliers, than for UK importers to interchange European suppliers.”

A number of the worst-hit commerce sectors have been meals, agriculture and fishing.

General, meals exports to the EU have taken a median hit of £2.8bn annually because the finish of the transition interval, in response to the Centre for Inclusive Commerce Coverage (CITP).

This 16 per cent common drop in meals and agricultural exports exhibits “no current indicators of regaining earlier ranges”, in response to the CITP report, and is impacted by burdensome border checks and administrative processes.

open picture in gallery

On the manufacturing aspect, farmers not profit from the EU’s widespread agricultural coverage, a considerable loss contemplating the UK’s personal cuts to farming subsidies.

The Lib Dems have estimated farming subsidies have fallen by 20 per cent in actual phrases since 2015 and the business has struggled with recruiting employees to fill shortages.

Inside the dairy enterprise, one in 12 farmers has needed to lower manufacturing in 2024, in response to a ballot from Arla Meals UK, with 56 per cent of dairy producers saying it’s more durable to recruit employees post-Brexit and Covid.

Customers are feeling the blowback from these pressures, too. Excessive inflation on meals and non-alcoholic drinks would have been 8 per cent decrease within the absence of Brexit, in response to a separate LSE research from 2023.

The paper’s authors say that there’s “sturdy proof that Brexit is the driving pressure behind these results”, separate to pressures from Covid and the Ukraine conflict.

open picture in gallery

As a part of its anti-EU marketing campaign, Nigel Farage’s Ukip celebration launched a poster collection in 2015 suggesting that UK fishing had been “ripped aside” by the EU.

But fishermen have been largely sad with post-Brexit phrases agreed within the TCA, with a French-British stalemate and continued restrictions on British fishing.

Seafood exports have dropped by 1 / 4 since 2019, from 454,000 tonnes a yr to 336,000 tonnes in 2023. This represents a financial drop of £283m, in response to the UK’s newest commerce statistics.

In December, Sir Keir struck a brand new EU fishing deal value £360m, which can enhance fishing alternatives by 15,000 tonnes (11 per cent).

open picture in gallery

One argument for Vote Depart, famously featured on posters and a “Brexit bus”, asserted that Britain despatched £350m per week to the EU, which may very well be higher spent on the NHS as a substitute.

It’s tough to say whether or not this cash-value sum, which might quantity to roughly £18.2bn a yr, has been diverted into the NHS.

When excluding emergency funding as a consequence of Covid, the deliberate NHS finances scarcely elevated in 2020/21 and 2021/22.

Nonetheless, from fiscal yr 2022/23, the core NHS finances jumped from £162.3bn to £185.4bn.

This finances was nonetheless decrease than the earlier yr when together with extra Covid spending.

In 2023, Vote Depart campaigner Michael Gove claimed that Brexit had “delivered” on its £350m NHS pledge, although no proof was supplied.

Given the overlap of Covid and Brexit, it is vitally tough to say whether or not cash saved from leaving the EU was spent on the NHS, and what incentives have been used to make funding choices.

Following the 2016 referendum, Mr Farage instantly mentioned he was unable to vow cash paid to the EU would as a substitute be spent on the NHS, saying: “No I can’t [guarantee it], and I might by no means have made that declare. That was one of many errors that I feel the Depart marketing campaign made.”

Migration: failed guarantees

A key precept of the Depart marketing campaign was to chop down on immigration. In an open letter to Mr Cameron within the Sunday Instances in 2016, Boris Johnson and Mr Gove wrote: “The promise [of curbing net migration] is plainly not achievable so long as the UK is a member of the EU and the failure to maintain it’s corrosive of public belief in politics.”

However leaving the EU didn’t have the meant impact on internet migration.

Although Britain left the EU in 2020, free motion was in place till January 2021. Since then, internet migration and immigration have soared.

Not less than 3.6 million immigrants have entered the UK since Brexit (between June 2021 and June 2024, the newest out there knowledge); with internet migration at 2.3 million over that interval.

Inside the first 12 months of Brexit immigration guidelines (as much as December 2021), internet migration jumped to 484,000; increased than any degree prior to now decade.

This trajectory has largely elevated; revised authorities figures for the yr ending June 2023 present record-breaking ranges of internet migration at 906,000 individuals.

Within the 4 years earlier than Brexit, internet migration was increased from EU nations than non-EU nations.

Since 2019, knowledge exhibits that almost all of internet migration to the UK comes from non-EU nations; with figures at 662,000 in 2023 alone.

In truth, since 2021 when Brexit guidelines got here into impact, internet migration from the EU has been unfavourable; which means that extra EU nationals are leaving the UK than coming to remain.

Between the Brexit referendum in 2016 and the tip of free motion in 2021, roughly 1,227,800 EU nationals emigrated from the UK. This was up by 58 per cent from the earlier five-year interval, in response to evaluation of figures from the Migration Observatory.

IEA economist Mr Jessop asserted that “some employees have benefited from increased wages because the UK turns into much less depending on cheaper migrant labour from the EU”.

Brexit arguably had the meant impact of curbing EU migration. However the broader migration image has concurrently ballooned.

The highest nations for non-EU immigration are India, Nigeria, Pakistan, China and Zimbabwe, in response to the newest ONS figures.

On account of Brexit, UK nationals additionally misplaced free motion to and throughout the EU.

The variety of EU-nationality college students in UK universities dropped from round 147,920 to 95,505 between 2019 and 2022, in response to the Greater Schooling Statistics Company.

College students from the EU beforehand paid residence charges for increased training, at round £9,000. Now, all worldwide college students (together with EU) pay increased charges, which might quantity to between £35,260 and £59,260 a yr at some equivalent to Oxford College.

There is no such thing as a central determine for the variety of British college students enrolled in EU universities. Nonetheless, British college students can not take pleasure in EU member charges for tuition charges in these establishments, that are as little as free in some universities.

British sovereignty

Although there are a number of methods by which Brexit has not met expectations, leaving the EU has allowed for extra flexibility in lawmaking.

Worth added tax (VAT) guidelines are one key space the place this has been utilised.

The EU has minimal VAT restrictions that apply throughout member states, with sure exemptions. When Britain was within the EU, it was not capable of lower VAT on inexperienced applied sciences like warmth pumps, for instance; although the EU has since lower VAT charges on photo voltaic panels.

It could additionally not have been potential to chop the notorious “tampon tax” underneath EU membership – since then, the EU has adopted swimsuit by permitting member states to exempt VAT on sanitary merchandise.

The current controversial transfer by Labour to cost VAT on personal faculty charges was additionally facilitated by Brexit, because the EU regulation designates training a VAT-exempt exercise.

Professional-Brexit former Tory cupboard minister Jacob Rees-Mogg mentioned the final 5 years had proven that “the EU is sinking quickly right into a regulatory mire which we’re nearly avoiding – no because of this authorities”.

Labour MP Stella Creasy, the chair of the Labour Motion for Europe, mentioned: ”The general public will not be fools – they know Brexit advantages are rarer than hens’ tooth. What they now want is lifelike options to the issues it’s inflicting like a youth mobility deal or rejoining the pan-European Mediterranean conference.”