We wasted thousands on state pension top-ups after WRONG advice – savers tell how their cash vanished

Savers who fell foul of the state pension top-ups system have accused the Authorities of encouraging them to make pointless funds, then failing to assist discover and refund their money.

Untold sums of top-ups money may very well be sitting in Authorities coffers, as a substitute of being repaid to people who find themselves nonetheless in the dead of night about what has occurred to their cash.

Kathryn Tattum, pictured proper, is amongst those that adopted official recommendation to verify with Authorities workers first, earlier than she handed over round £3,300 in Could final 12 months within the perception it could increase her state pension.

The retired native authorities officer solely found she had been misinformed after interesting to That is Cash to assist discover her lacking cash practically a 12 months later.

‘I did be certain that. I checked with them first,’ she informed us. ‘I spoke to 2 or three individuals on the Division for Work and Pensions and at no time did they are saying do not ship cash.

‘All they informed me after I rang up is there’s a backlog. The system is so overwhelmed nobody is taking accountability.’

Sylvia Popplestone paid £5,700 final October after a four-month look forward to a letter from the DWP that confirmed this quantity would improve her state pension.

After That is Cash intervened and coated the case of her lacking state pension top-ups in January, she was subsequently informed she had overpaid by £4,600 – however the backlog for refunds was 9 weeks.

Why are individuals complaining about state pension top-up chaos?

Pissed off savers have complained of state pension top-ups chaos for the previous 12 months, and immediately we cowl FOUR circumstances in complete of misplaced money and workers giving mistaken info or unable to assist.

The Authorities has promised a brand new on-line service that can enable individuals to verify if shopping for top-ups will increase their state pension and to make funds. 

Regardless of its assurances this must be prepared by early April, it has been delayed and there’s no begin date but.

Shopping for top-ups may give a beneficiant increase to retirement revenue when you purchase the proper years in your file.

The system was overwhelmed early final 12 months when a rush of consumers jammed phonelines forward of a crunch deadline to purchase top-ups going again to 2006, fairly than the standard six years

That finally pressured the Authorities to increase it twice, now to April 2025.

The scheme, run collectively by HMRC and the DWP, is complicated and it’s straightforward to make harmless errors, or ring up the mistaken division as a result of you do not know which one handles every stage of the acquisition, or at what level it may need gone awry.

The method presently entails contacting the DWP, which checks and tells you which of them years are value topping up; acquiring a reference quantity from HMRC earlier than making a purchase order; HMRC taking the fee for further contributions after which updating Nationwide Insurance coverage information; then the DWP recalculating state pension forecasts or funds.

Shopping for top-ups is predicted to be easier and simpler as soon as the brand new on-line service begins, however it’s unclear if the next updating of NI information and state pension funds may even be streamlined.

There’s additionally a pile of ‘unallocated’ money to be handled, the place funds haven’t been processed for unknown causes, or refunds are owed.

Former Pensions Minister and That is Cash retirement columnist Steve Webb says: ‘State pension top-ups are an advanced enterprise and it could possibly simply occur that voluntary contributions end up so as to add nothing to your pension.

‘However no-one in Whitehall appears to assume it’s their job to be sure you get your a reimbursement. HMRC will say they’ve accurately up to date your NI file. And DWP will say that they’ve accurately checked for any improved state pension.

‘However the poor taxpayer is left in the dead of night except they chase issues up. We’d like a system the place, if DWP determine no state pension improve is due, they be certain that the voluntary contributions are refunded. They can not simply sit on the cash.’

Webb, who’s now a accomplice at LCP, provides: ‘In different circumstances, contributions have been made however sit in some type of suspense account, not even getting so far as being added to the proper NI file.

‘As soon as once more, it doesn’t appear to be anybody’s job to undergo these unallocated contributions and both do one thing with them or pay them again.

‘We urgently have to put the contributor on the coronary heart of this course of in order that both they get an enhanced pension or their a reimbursement, as a substitute of being left in limbo.’

Liberal Democrat Work and Pensions spokesperson, Wendy Chamberlain, says: ‘It’s utterly unacceptable that DWP workers are giving out the mistaken recommendation and inflicting individuals to pay hundreds of kilos after which undergo the extra stress of requesting refunds.

‘It beggars perception that the Authorities tells individuals to name for steering which it seems is totally unreliable.’

‘This actually provides insult to damage for individuals who have already gone by way of lengthy ready durations, and infrequently seen their cash disappear right into a system with out hint.

‘We urgently want the introduction of receipts so that individuals have a transparent paper path of the place their cash is; and an entire overview of the Future Pension Centre and the recommendation it’s offering. Promising a web-based system sooner or later is not any consolation if the DWP can’t be trusted to perform at even a fundamental degree.’

Former Pensions Minister Ros Altmann, a longtime pensions campaigner who now sits within the Home of Lords, says of the circumstances we spotlight immediately: ‘I really feel very sorry for all these individuals who have paid cash in good religion, have been given incorrect info, should spend hours attempting to retrieve the cash they paid unnecessarily and have to attend so lengthy for his or her right state pension funds to reach or information to be up to date.’

She provides: ‘That is yet one more worrying instance of how the ludicrous complexity of our state pension system – each below the previous guidelines and below the brand new guidelines – is costing many members of the general public vital time to attempt to type out their entitlements, monumental further price to the DWP and HMRC in administration and vital nervousness when those that name up are given the mistaken info and can’t type this out with out the intervention of That is Cash.

‘How the system was ever allowed to change into so sophisticated is a crucial query, and one which politicians have to be taught from for the longer term.’

A Authorities spokesperson says: ‘A brand new on-line service to permit most individuals to see if making voluntary contributions would improve their state pension, and make funds, will probably be launched quickly. 

‘Extra info will probably be launched sooner or later.

‘During the last 12 months, a whole bunch of hundreds of individuals have contacted us about voluntary contributions, with the overwhelming majority of funds leading to information being up to date inside days.

‘Advanced circumstances requiring specialist caseworkers can take longer to resolve – however we’re making good progress on lowering wait instances.’ 

Learn extra on what the Authorities says about shopping for top-ups and getting refunds under.

‘All they informed me after I rang up is there’s a backlog’

Kathryn Tattum contacted the DWP and HMRC a number of instances final 12 months, earlier than and after she made a £3,300 top-up fee in Could, however wasn’t warned it could not improve her state pension.

The 68-year-old from Larger Manchester stored a file of first names of workers she spoke to and dates of three events when she phoned both DWP or HMRC.

‘They mentioned go forward and we are going to ship you a hyperlink and a reference quantity. At no level did anybody say you bought the mistaken recommendation,’ she informed us.

That features in August, when she began attempting to hint the place her cash had gone. Mrs Tattum says no workers member informed her they’d look into it, so alternatives to search out out what had occurred and get her a refund earlier had been missed.

After she turned to That is Cash, the Authorities informed us HMRC had up to date her NI file in Could and DWP was routinely knowledgeable.

Nevertheless, the essential info that these contributions wouldn’t enhance Mrs Tattum’s state pension and she or he wanted to use for a refund was by no means given to her till we flagged her case final month, and helped her get the cash again.

She informed us: ‘I nonetheless cannot perceive how I used to be initially informed that I might buy further NI years, then the way it took you to get entangled for somebody to look into it, solely to find it wasn’t going to enhance my state pension. The cash might have been incomes curiosity elsewhere.’

‘Scale of the ineptitude and inefficiency on the DWP and HMRC is simply mind-boggling’

Sylvia Popplestone and her husband Paul, pictured above, tried from June to October in 2023 to get info from the DWP about which years to purchase to spice up her state pension.

The 66-year-old retired campsite employee solely made a purchase order after receiving a letter from the DWP, which mentioned she ought to pay £5,700.

We coated the experiences of the couple, who reside in France, in a narrative in January when Mr Popplestone mentioned the state pension top-ups system was in ‘complete chaos’ and ‘clearly damaged’.

After its publication, Mrs Popplestone obtained a letter from HMRC saying she was eligible for a refund of round £4,600 as a result of the DWP had now suggested she ought to have paid Class 2 contributions, that are for self-employed individuals.

She utilized to get her a reimbursement at the beginning of March, and when her husband tried to chase it up on the telephone he was informed refunds are presently taking 9 weeks to course of.

Nevertheless, she has now obtained the refund after That is Cash took up her case once more with HMRC and the DWP.

Mr and Mrs Popplestone really feel she is owed some redress for the lengthy delays, misinformation given to her, and the pointless fee which might have been incomes 4.25 per cent curiosity of their financial savings account.

He informed us: ‘We now really feel that it’s simply not proper that individuals are dropping out in such a manner for errors and inefficient dealing with dedicated by the DWP and HMRC.

‘And equally, that by “simply letting it experience”, we’re in some way complicit in letting them get away with individuals dropping out and never offering the DWP/HMRC with any incentive to type issues out for others.

‘I’ve to say that this actually goes towards the grain for us as we’re not in any respect individuals who search compensation usually as we perceive that real errors happen.

‘However the scale of the ineptitude and inefficiency on the DWP and HMRC is simply mind-boggling and the disingenuous replies they supply solely serve to create the impression that they would like to say that there is no such thing as a downside, which simply demonstrates a complete lack of sincerity with respect to them genuinely attempting to repair the issues.’ 

‘HMRC had my cash for simply over six months’

Simon Richardson, 71, paid £1,650 for state pension top-ups in October 2023, however solely after calling HMRC to verify if he might fill gaps in his Nationwide Insurance coverage file.

He was informed by a workers member he might purchase two years of contributions to qualify for a full state pension.

Nevertheless, when That is Cash flagged his case, it turned out that his NI file was up to date after the fee, and the DWP had been routinely knowledgeable – however neither division alerted him this may not enhance his state pension.

Mr Richardson, a retired civil servant who lives in Cornwall, says: ‘The preliminary HMRC adviser had sight of my NI file and will have knowledgeable me at that time that I had paid the utmost variety of NI years contributions and due to this fact there was no profit in me buying extra years.’

He provides: ‘HMRC had my cash for simply over six months. I hope they invested it properly. Maybe any cash earned would assist fund an upgraded assist desk?

‘I feel that, with out your assist, I might have nonetheless been ready for HMRC to replace DWP after which DWP to inform me the extra NI years bought had made no distinction to my pension, after which HMRC to write down to me…and so forth!’

Mr Richardson has now obtained a refund.

‘I bought no receipt for my top-up cash’

Diana Robinson (title modified) paid round £1,400 for state pension top-ups in February 2023, however then her cash appeared to fade.

The 62-year-old retired clerical employee from Liverpool requested us for assist, saying: ‘I bought no receipt for this cash nor has it been posted to my account but. I do know they’re in a little bit of a large number and I do know my case is not pressing however I wish to have a receipt.’

That is Cash says state pension top-ups are in dire want of an overhaul by DWP and HMRC 

That is Cash has made calls to motion to repair chaos in top-ups system.

1) Create one state pension top-ups division, below one boss, that offers with your entire top-ups course of from begin to end, whether or not on-line or offline.

2) Discover out the place the present worst delays are taking place, which might be simpler if there weren’t two departments that may blame one another, after which type out the bottlenecks.

3) Revamp the decision centre operation so individuals who ring up about top-ups obtain assist with their downside, by introducing an efficient filtering system so all queries are handled, whereas probably the most severe points are despatched up the road.

4) Do a sweep for the oldest complaints about top-ups, nevertheless intractable they may look, and get a trouble-shooting crew onto them.

> THIS IS MONEY COMMENT: Older individuals want a reliable division to deal with state pension points

When Mrs Robinson initially rang up about shopping for top-ups final 12 months, she was informed there was a six week backlog.

After we raised her case, HMRC discovered her fee and DWP up to date her state pension forecast.

She informed us: ‘Many thanks, it could not have occurred with out your assist.’

What does the Authorities say?

The DWP and MRC offered the next info on the state pension top-ups system.

– Voluntary contributions don’t all the time improve your state pension and you need to be sure you would profit earlier than making any funds.

– The Authorities has prolonged the deadline to five April 2025 to offer individuals extra time to fill gaps of their Nationwide Insurance coverage file going again to 2006, fairly than the standard six-year backdating interval.

– Nearly all of individuals, together with these residing overseas who need to pay voluntary contributions for years they had been resident within the UK, ought to be capable of use a brand new on-line digital service which HMRC and DWP are aiming to introduce as soon as improvement and testing is full. 

Steerage will probably be given on GOV.UK on who can use the brand new digital service and the way.

– The service will probably be launched as quickly as doable after the standard replace to the Nationwide Insurance coverage system at the beginning of the brand new tax 12 months, so clients can repeatedly entry the service with out interruption. 

The Authorities has informed us the NI replace was meant to happen by 9 April, with the net service launching quickly after this.

– This can enable the service to have in mind the April state pension improve for 2024/25, to make sure customers see probably the most up-to-date info on how a lot further state pension they might obtain by paying to fill gaps of their NI file.

– On the finish of January, a digital software course of for top-ups overlaying durations spent residing or working overseas was launched, which means individuals now not should put up a CF83 kind.

– The Authorities is frequently working to assist extra individuals get entry to its on-line companies whereas preserving their info safe. Worldwide clients can confirm their id utilizing GOV.UK ID Verify app to entry this and different companies.

– The DWP goals to replace state pension information as quickly as doable as soon as notified HMRC has allotted a fee to somebody’s Nationwide Insurance coverage file.

– Funds requiring guide processing, for instance these made by cheque, and extra advanced circumstances requiring additional checks together with postal purposes from overseas, can take longer to resolve relying on particular person circumstances.

– HMRC has further workers answering telephone calls and coping with correspondence on voluntary contributions, together with requests for refunds, and all contact is handled on a case-by-case foundation. When somebody rings or writes to HMRC, it goals to resolve their question at first contact, but when additional investigation is required that is observe on exercise and the client is made conscious of this.

– Functions for refunds are processed on a case by case foundation, relying on particular person circumstances, and HMRC goals to answer such requests as quickly as doable.

– If you happen to’re under state pension age, contact the Future Pension Centre to search out out when you’ll profit from voluntary contributions. If you happen to’ve reached state pension age, contact the Pension Service.

That is Cash podcast