what stories of soldiers’ unexpected battlefield meetings reveal about the trauma of war

James Brady, serving with the Royal Military Medical Corps within the first world struggle, struggled to relate the second he was taken captive by German troopers whereas serving on the western entrance. Within the draft of his memoir, he crossed out and rewrote this part repeatedly.

Central to his account is what he known as a “weird human incident” by which a “baby-faced Jerry”, talking good cockney English, approached him and gave him {a photograph} of himself, asking Brady to maintain it “as a memento”:

A younger German standing close to immediately nudged me and with a wink stated: ‘Hiya child, how outdated are you then?’ Shocked, I whispered: ‘Twenty – how outdated are you?’ There didn’t appear a lot else I might say. ‘Nineteen,’ replied the baby-faced Jerry. ‘Lived in Balham until I used to be 15.’

Brady, from Rochdale in Lancashire, had been rejected by military recruiters for being underage and missing the bodily necessities. He managed to enlist within the Royal Military Medical Corps (RAMC) and joined a subject ambulance unit on the Somme in August 1916, aged 17. He was taken prisoner at Essigny in northern France on March 21 1918, the primary morning of the German spring offensive, when the enemy captured his dugout. He described the approaching risk of a senior German officer, “puce with rage, threatening to shoot all people in sight” except he was instructed the place of the British cannon.

Because the altercation continued, the British machine gun battery opened hearth and a British ambulance man was shot. Brady was uncertain in regards to the chain of occasions, querying in a single draft whether or not the person was killed by the German officer or by the crossfire from British weapons.

I got here throughout Brady’s memoir, which was by no means revealed, within the archives of the Imperial Struggle Museums (IWM) as a part of a venture exploring battlefield encounters all through the previous century, by which enemies have met and generally reassessed each other as human beings. Brady had been interviewed for the IWM’s first world struggle oral historical past venture in 1990.

Each certainly one of his makes an attempt to explain that traumatic seize included an account of his extraordinary assembly with the younger cockney-speaking German soldier – an encounter which punctuated his concern and “etched itself on my reminiscence”:

With a fast look at his belligerent ober-lieutenant, he took a snapshot from his tunic pocket and confirmed me {a photograph} of a gaggle of three younger troopers. ‘That’s me within the center. Right here, maintain it as a memento.’ I used to be flabbergasted … I took the image and stuffed it in my tunic pocket.

The {photograph} grew to become a treasured possession. Drafting his memoir 60 years later, Brady wrote: “That snapshot remains to be amongst my souvenirs.” The assembly seems to have altered his notion of the brutal struggle by which he fought. He referred to the German as “my pleasant enemy” and “my German-cockney pal”.

Over the previous 5 years, I’ve researched truces, remedy of the wounded, and the taking of prisoners in many various struggle settings. Particularly, I’ve sought out these uncommon moments of enemy intimacy akin to Brady skilled, and would keep in mind for the remainder of his life.

On the eve of Armistice Day, I share these troopers’ experiences – from the primary world struggle to newer accounts of serving in Northern Eire and Libya – as a counterpoint to the insularity, suspicion and “othering” that’s usually prevalent in at present’s conflicted world. These tales, in distinction, are in regards to the energy of unlikely friendships.

‘How might you be my enemy?’

A museum archivist solid doubt on components of Brady’s story, noting there was “some indication that components of the memoir could have been exaggerated”. However the incident of the gifted {photograph} seems important to Brady’s telling of his seize – it was the a part of his memoir he discovered most troublesome to write down, as evidenced by the variety of instances he crossed it out and began once more.

My analysis exhibits Brady’s expertise was removed from uncommon. Enemy encounters have been usually enabled by the trade of items, together with foodstuffs (even chewed biltong within the South African struggle), alcohol, tobacco, addresses, private letters, newspapers, crucifixes, watches, garments and Christmas items.

The Insights part is dedicated to high-quality longform journalism. Our editors work with teachers from many various backgrounds who’re tackling a variety of societal and scientific challenges.

Key texts within the canon of struggle literature, together with Leo Tolstoy’s Struggle And Peace, Erich Remarque’s All Quiet On The Western Entrance, in addition to poetry by Wilfred Owen, Robert Service and Keith Douglas, all use the trade of private results between enemies to discover the emotions of what Owen known as a “unusual assembly”. Remarque’s novel particulars his German narrator’s discovery of letters and images within the pockets of the enemy he has killed:

Now I can see your spouse and your face, and realise what we’ve got in frequent. Forgive me, comrade. We at all times see it too late. Why do they by no means inform us that you’re poor devils like us, that your moms are simply as anxious as ours, and that we’ve got the identical concern of demise, and the identical dying and the identical agony. Forgive me, comrade; how might you be my enemy?

In his 1916 poem My Prisoner, Service – who, like Brady, was serving with a RAMC ambulance unit – describes a German soldier presenting a locket with an image of his three-year-old daughter to his British (cockney) captor, who responds by displaying an image of his personal little daughter:

And we talks as pleasant as will be;

Then I ‘elps ‘im on ‘is method,

‘Opes ‘e’s protected at ‘ome at present,

Wonders: ‘Ow would ‘e ‘ave handled me?

As on this case, it’s sometimes prisoners who hand over private objects to dealer relationships, purchase time, or diffuse a right away risk to their security. They’re usually compelled handy over valuables akin to army decorations, wallets and pocket-watches. The historian Brian Feltman has argued that the plundering of prisoners is a part of the enactment of energy over them, growing captives’ emotions of disgrace and emasculation.

However Brady’s expertise bucked this development, with certainly one of his German captors giving him, their prisoner, {a photograph}. The motion of that “baby-faced Jerry” factors to a way of disgrace that captors can generally expertise. He took motion to humanise himself, conveying goodwill by an object that might reassure each Brady and himself of his distinction to his “belligerent ober-lieutenant”.

Although he by no means noticed the German cockney once more, Brady wrote of how different cases of German sympathy helped alleviate his time as a prisoner of struggle. On the march to jail after his seize, he recalled how the British sang to keep up morale:

Our younger Bavarian guards, most of them little greater than boys, quickened their tempo with ours and smiled at us wanly, pityingly. A few times, I caught a few of them selecting up the tune and buzzing quietly together with us.

Brady additionally described how their guards turned away French girls who have been attempting to deliver meals to the British prisoners – however solely “somewhat reluctantly, I assumed”. And his expertise of confinement was improved by a younger Prussian officer who taught him to play chess: “Fritz (his actual title) was a pleasant character, spoke good English and was endowed with limitless persistence.” Brady lastly returned to Britain on December 2 1919, his twenty first birthday.

Whereas violence to prisoners – unlawful beneath the worldwide legal guidelines of struggle established within the mid-Nineteenth century – is frequent in lots of conflicts, I’ve additionally discovered recurrent cases of captor disgrace. The taking of prisoners can provoke in some a type of existential disaster: in regards to the humanity of 1’s personal facet in addition to the enemy, and the legitimacy of army violence and even struggle itself.

Casual practices of ‘dwell and let dwell’

Probably the most well-known pleasant encounters between enemies in British tradition are the mythologised recreation of soccer and trade of items throughout the Christmas Day truce of 1914. Actually, there have been many Christmas ceasefires alongside the western entrance that yr, and truces continued to emerge on this and different fronts, together with between Anzac and Ottoman troopers at Gallipoli.

Such truces have been nothing new for older troopers who had served within the South African struggle of 1899-1902, when Sunday ceasefires have been broadly adopted in response to the Boer reluctance to battle on the Sabbath. They usually have been usually formally agreed for collections of the lifeless and wounded, with enemies interacting cordially in these aftermaths of battle.

However extra casual practices of “dwell and let dwell” additionally characterised the western entrance throughout the first world struggle, as army historian Tony Ashworth has documented. These included respecting mealtimes and bathroom websites, and exchanging provisions and small luxuries throughout enemy strains – as Corporal Louis Barthas, a French infantryman, recalled in his diary throughout the summer time of 1916:

Exchanges of items like packets of tobacco from the Régie Française went to fill the large German pipes, [while] scrumptious German cigarettes came visiting to the French facet. We additionally exchanged lighters, buttons, newspapers, bread. Right here was a loopy enterprise of commerce and intelligence which might have stirred up the indignation of patriots and superpatriots.

However even when troopers reached out to their enemy, they tended to take action alongside class and racial strains. Commonalities of rank or race might reinforce current energy hierarchies on either side. The popularity of fellowship between foes usually operated to exclude others, particularly girls and black troopers.

Within the South African struggle, fraternisation between Boer and British forces confirmed ideologies of superiority of two colonial powers, sustaining the fiction of this “white man’s struggle” by ignoring the main contributions of black scouts and forces on either side.

This echoes the racialised patterns of fraternisation seen throughout the American civil struggle (1861-5). As historian Lauren Thompson describes in her e-book Pleasant Enemies, moments of brotherhood between Union and Accomplice troops have been “denied to black males, and can be indicative of race relations in postwar America”.

The stolen pocket watch

{A photograph} was on the coronary heart of one other encounter between a British first world struggle soldier and the younger German he took prisoner. Years later, Donald Worth admitted stealing the German’s pocket watch – which is now within the IWM archive – throughout their encounter in a shell crater in 1918, recalling with remorse how he took the watch from this “little German fella” who was “solely about 16”.

I used to be very sorry for him actually. We had a chinwag, I gave him a cigarette … He was a pleasant little chap, however I simply took [the watch], – it was the traditional factor. They’d take ours so we used to rob them … He was a prisoner, he couldn’t object.

Contained in the watch, {a photograph} exhibits this very younger German soldier in uniform sitting together with his girlfriend – each smiling as they make eye contact with future viewers of the picture. Over the soldier’s shoulder, some white trellis work makes the form of a cross.

The non-public nature of this watch-locket made Worth pause for thought – in distinction with different watches he had robbed from enemy troopers:

I usually thought I made a mistake in not sending the {photograph} again to Germany as quickly because the struggle had completed – to see if he was nonetheless alive and what occurred to his household.

Maybe in another type of reparation, Worth donated the watch to the IWM. In a subsequent interview, his voice cracked as he described his remorse that it was “a kind of issues I simply forgot to do – little chap, he was”.

His audible discomfort resonates with my findings of captor disgrace. This neglected emotion recurs in lots of recollections, and fictional accounts, of the seize of prisoners of struggle all through the twentieth century.

Julian Grenfell, for instance, discovered his normally easy, aggressive angle to the enemy was challenged when taking prisoners. The British first world struggle officer cheerfully recorded killing Germans – conserving a “recreation e-book” by which he listed human kills alongside the partridges he had bagged. But in letters to his mom, he described how assembly captive enemies made him really feel “ashamed”:

We took a German officer and a few males prisoners in a wooden the opposite day. I felt hatred for them after our lifeless, and because the officer got here by me, I scowled at him … [He] regarded me within the face and saluted me as he handed; and I’ve by no means seen a person look so proud and resolute and sensible and assured, in his hour of bitterness. He made me really feel terribly ashamed of myself.

Struggle And Peace (1869) – a novel knowledgeable by Tolstoy’s experiences as an officer within the Caucasus and Crimean wars, in addition to troopers’ memoirs from the Napoleonic wars – captures this unease brilliantly. Nikolai Rostov, previously a bellicose Russian officer, is discomforted by proximity to the French enemy he takes prisoner:

This pale, mud-stained face of a fair-haired younger man with a dimple on his chin and vivid blue eyes had no enterprise with battlefields. It was not the face of an enemy; it was a home, indoor face.

Tolstoy presents Rostov’s emotions on taking this prisoner as onerous to outline, however they definitely aren’t triumph or satisfaction. Moderately, he experiences an unanchored “nasty feeling inside, an aching spherical his coronary heart … one thing imprecise and confused that he couldn’t account for”.

‘I used to be holding his household in my arms’

Encounters with the enemy throughout battle have modified as a consequence of new applied sciences that allow killing at better distance. However these haven’t utterly displaced direct contact between floor troops, as some incidents throughout the Russia-Ukraine struggle have proven. Intimate methods of partaking with the enemy – whether or not by trade of private possessions, remedy of the wounded, or take care of prisoners – persist even in these very completely different contexts.

Within the Eighties throughout the Iran-Iraq struggle, Iranian soldier Zahed Haftlung had a complete reversal of mindset on seeing a wounded Iraqi enemy’s {photograph} of their spouse and younger little one. Haftlung had been ordered to take no prisoners throughout the 1982 battle of Khorramshahr. Then he got here throughout a severely wounded enemy soldier sheltering in a bunker.

Haflung would later describe aiming his rifle on the soldier, who held up his Koran in a plea to be spared. Contained in the e-book, Haftlung found {a photograph} of the person’s household:

The infant’s face was in profile, nevertheless it was so younger that its pores and skin was nonetheless vivid crimson. The lady’s darkish eyes solid a spell, like she might look straight into my secrets and techniques. There was one thing about her gaze, a disappointment that made me need to maintain her hand and inform her that all the things was going to be OK. I knew I used to be holding his household in my arms. These have been the individuals who liked him, who would die inside if I killed him.

The transformative energy of this {photograph} kinds a part of the memoir Haftlung later co-authored with Najah Aboud – the wounded enemy he had saved. The story of their outstanding post-war reunion and friendship can also be the topic of Ann Shin’s documentary, My Enemy My Brother.

One other unlikely friendship, between a Guantanamo detainee and his American guard, is documented within the Guardian movie My Brother’s Keeper. Steve Wooden’s worldview was reshaped by his friendship with Mauritainian detainee Mohamedou Ould Slahi, who was held at Guantánamo Bay for 14 years with out cost on suspicion of involvement within the September 11 assaults.

Wooden’s admiration of Slahi’s resilience beneath torture and indefinite detention impressed his conversion to Islam. He described the hole between the vicious enemy he’d been led to count on and the person he present in Slahi as “my matrix second in life … I simply didn’t know what to imagine”.

Wooden and Slahi promote their friendship in a venture to alter minds and insurance policies. Slahi’s 2015 e-book, Guantánamo Diary, and the characteristic movie on which it’s primarily based are all a part of their effort to shut Guantánamo and finish indefinite detention. Their story, and lots of others, counteract the over-simplified narrative that struggle is rising more and more impersonal.

Veterans’ tales of ethical harm

I regarded on everybody as a human being … They have been struggling, so I wished to assist.

Graham, a British veteran, is reflecting on his remedy of wounded prisoners following a riot on the Northern Eire jail by which he was stationed within the Seventies. By my work with the veterans’ part of arts charity Re-Reside, I might examine historic accounts of enemy encounters with Graham’s experiences throughout the Troubles. He describes himself as having been only a “spotty teenager” on the time.

These conversations with Graham and different veterans, and broader life-story work, helped to form Coming Residence (2022), a comic book made by the Re-Reside group in partnership with editor Steve Sullivan {and professional} illustrators. Coming Residence recounts 4 of those veterans’ experiences of enemies inside and exterior.

Graham’s “Stretcher-bearer Stan” returns to the positioning of a very traumatic incident. The narrative of a younger bandsman named Stan, working the gate at Lengthy Kesh jail in Northern Eire – which held Republican and Loyalist internees from 1971-1974 – is intercut with the veteran’s return a long time later, as he processes his experiences. The main focus is on a jail riot by which Stan treats wounded “enemies”, and is due to this fact accused of missing loyalty.

This story echoes Tolstoy’s earlier exploration of Rostov’s disconcertment on coming head to head together with his enemy. In each narratives, cognitive and ethical dissonance outcomes from the hole between the enemy the troopers had been ready to fulfill by their coaching and tradition, and the precise people they encountered.

Robbie’s story, “Secure Haven”, is about within the Gulf Struggle in 1991. Tasked with offering displaced Kurdish civilians susceptible to genocide with “protected passage again to their properties and ongoing safety”, the marine is left questioning: “So it is a humanitarian mission?”

Secure Haven particulars the hospitality of the Kurdish folks, and the marine’s rising intimacy with Ahmed, who declares: “My adopted son, you’re a part of my household” – simply earlier than the order comes for British forces to maneuver out. This story recollects a traumatic expertise of attachment, shifted allegiance and betrayal.

Our conversations with these veterans recommend that historic expressions of strangeness and uneasiness throughout sudden enemy encounters have been early examples of what’s now understood as “ethical harm”. There may be rising consideration to this distinct type of trauma, which might create completely different psychological well being challenges and require particular therapeutic approaches.

In a standalone art work for the comedian, illustrator Casey Raymond presents the work of repairing the guts as a type of kintsugi, a Japanese course of by which damaged ceramics are re-pieced with gold.

Analysis led by Victoria Williamson recognized ethical harm in veterans who had “skilled an occasion or occasions that challenged their view of who they’re, the world they dwell in, or their moral sense”. This constructed on a examine of probably morally injurious occasions described by UK army veterans, which highlighted considerations round mistreating the opposite facet – each civilians and enemy combatants.

In Struggle and Peace, Rostov’s emotions about his behaviour in the direction of his enemy are described as “a form of regret” – he “nonetheless felt embarrassed and one way or the other ashamed”. In Williamson’s examine, a core identifier of ethical harm was this type of response, “the place the first emotion expressed was of guilt or disgrace”.

‘The enemy narrative has modified’

There’s a sample amongst our historic analysis – additionally seen in Graham’s Stretcher-bearer Stan – whereby a bewildering change in standing or energy happens when folks beforehand seen as enemies start to be understood as struggling, wounded people in want of care. This shift can result in a protracted and painful strategy of reassessment by which former certainties, identities and allegiances are not dependable.

Throughout an occasion on the Museum of Navy Medication in Surrey, Graham spoke in regards to the profoundly life-changing expertise of offering care to either side after the riot at Lengthy Kesh:

In the midst of that evening, I modified from a spotty teenager into somebody who’d skilled some terrible issues in life.

This resonated with the experiences of volunteer nurse-turned-peace activist Asma Khalifa, when she was treating enemy troopers in Libya in the summertime of 2011. Working as a subject nurse for the opposition to Colonel Muammar Gaddafi’s regime, Asma put herself ahead to take care of Gaddafi troopers who had been uncared for in a army hospital.

Having misplaced her greatest pal within the battle and with a brother and uncles preventing for the opposition, she maintained a strict manner on the wards, avoiding speaking and eye-contact. However on an early-morning antibiotics spherical, a soldier met her eyes and stated: “You make me really feel inhuman.” Asma later described this as “one of the impactful moments of my life”:

After I checked out him, he appeared precisely the identical as me … the identical ache, the identical vulnerability, the identical concern, the identical understanding of this devastation we have been going by.

Asma and this soldier prisoner cried collectively, a second she described as inflicting “a elementary shift” in her. “Ever since, I don’t consider anybody as an enemy … My conditioning for accepting the enemy narrative has modified.”

The dialog between Graham and Asma, who has acquired awards for her peace activism, thought-about the dehumanisation and rehumanisation of each the enemy and the self throughout battle. Such discussions have made a strong distinction to my scholarship – encouraging me to learn each Struggle and Peace and the primary world struggle troopers’ tales afresh, and to recognise the connections between captor disgrace and ethical harm.

I imagine the examine of those transformative relationships with the enemy will help us higher perceive the emotional and psychological complexities of warfare at present – when, as Asma put it, “my conditioning for accepting the enemy narrative has modified”. In the meantime Graham, in working with Re-Reside to inform his story and have it heard, concluded:

This therapeutic course of is enabling me to know who I’m – and the way this story affected me. Importantly, the change is that I can speak now with out shaking or something. I in all probability wouldn’t have been in a position to try this this time final yr.

Holly Furneaux will co-host an occasion discussing the historical past of enemy encounters on the Temple of Peace, Cardiff on Thursday, November 14 from 5-7pm.

For you: extra from our Insights collection:

To listen to about new Insights articles, be part of the a whole lot of hundreds of people that worth The Dialog’s evidence-based information. Subscribe to our e-newsletter.